06 Article Kallsen Do The Math H1

Do the math!

In a world where we can go from a CAD model to a 3D printed part well within a typical working day, it’s easy to get excited about just how fast one can iterate and explore design alternatives.

As engineers, we can't forget that as the excitement of the creation within a conceptualization phase comes to a crescendo, a critical step in comparing design alternatives and detailing out a preferred approach involves completing tolerance stacks. A tolerance stack is simply an analysis of how the various components of a design will fit and/or perform together based on the anticipated components’ dimensional differences, which will be seen in production.

Depending on the criticality of what is being designed, a tolerance stack can be scaled as appropriate — think medical device versus a pencil box. In the case of a pencil box, a couple hand calculations and you may be well on your way to a final design with very low risk of issues. Now contrast that to a complicated disposable medical device that has dozens of interacting components made from several multi-cavity tools to keep up with the millions of devices needed each year — you better have a robust tolerance stack analysis method. It is the latter scenario that has driven the latest revisions in our tolerance stack methods.

While certain scenarios justify advanced tolerance analysis methods such as 3D Monte Carlo Simulations, we still see significant value in more traditional 2D tolerance stacks. Certainly, one of the most challenging aspects of a tolerance analysis is maintaining it as the program transitions through first-article approvals, pilot production, and eventually process validation.

The original tolerance stack is usually based on a compromise between what the development team is hoping for and the operations team and vendor base is willing to sign up for. As the production process is ramped up and optimized, the realities of what is possible can then be run back through the tolerance analysis.

Faced with the challenge of needing a living analysis document that is robust and easy to navigate, a couple motivated Design Concepts engineers (Randy Koplin and Andrew Joncich) flexed their Excel spreadsheet muscles and took our tolerance analysis spreadsheet to the next level.

With this new proprietary tolerance analysis spreadsheet, complete with an index that helps an engineer find every place that a particular dimension impacts the design and the standard practice of pasting in CAD images that help illustrate the dimensions, I dare say tolerance stacks may in fact now be a joy to do. Thanks, Randy and Andrew for the grassroots efforts to continue to make us better and more efficient at what we do!

CES Web Transportation
CES 2021: Transportation tech promises a cleaner, safer future
The vehicle expo area of CES has been one of the most exciting parts of the trade show in recent years.
Ricardo gomez angel Pqku Jqzghew unsplash
Transforming Engineering
The list of industries experiencing huge disruption fueled by “technology” is growing by the day.
Face Shield on Mannikin for Banner
Top 5 lessons from Badger Shield project
Badger Shield gave me the opportunity to collaborate with an amazing group of men and women this year – designers, suppliers, manufacturers, and customers. I expect to have built lifelong collaborators and friends through this trial by virus. (For background, read the article in Wired).
Michael marais Hj V h EE Cgc M unsplash
13 Biggest Innovations of 2019 To Influence Product Design
Robots unleashed; the emergence of hearables; sustainable plastics and processes — we weigh in the biggest innovations of 2019 to influence product design.
HEADER Flap Jawn 2
Our DIY Split-Flap Display: An Adventure in Inefficient Nostalgia
We weren't setting out to invent something radically different, but we wanted to prove to ourselves that we could make our own split-flap display.
Austin-distel-w D1LRb9Oe Eo-unsplash
Running Effective Engineering Design Reviews
The term design review can have a lot of different meanings depending on the context in which it is used.