Kevin Murphy THUMB

Kevin Murphy

Engineering

Electrical & Software Engineering

There are a lot of great reasons why your digital-physical device might benefit from a touchscreen display.&nbsp;
Digital interfaces can be more intuitive, powerful, and scalable — assuming good interaction and user experience design, of course.&nbsp;
For applications requiring significant levels of information, feedback, and interactions, there may be no alternative.
At Delve, we design lots of devices with digital interfaces. A frequent question we get from clients is, What kind of touchscreen display is best for our product?
If you’re at the beginning of your product development process and you’re not sure if your embedded device’s graphical user interface (GUI) should take the form of a custom embedded display or a commercially available, off-the-shelf (OTS) tablet or smartphone, like an iPhone, you’re not alone.

SM INLINE Custom V Shelf

The short answer is that any of the above could work.&nbsp;
The long answer? The appropriate choice varies by application and context of use. In this article, we’ll explain the most important factors to consider — product risk, development budget and timeline, user experience, lifecycle management, and cost of goods sold — and questions to ask yourself while you’re making this decision.

INLINE 01 Custom V Shelf BLOG template NEW 05

<h2>1: Have You Determined Potential Safety Risks?</h2>
For medical devices and other safety-critical applications such as transportation and infrastructure, you’ll need to consider potential safety risks and mitigations.&nbsp;
Evaluate whether the use of an off-the-shelf phone or tablet could create an unsafe or unsecure situation during the device’s use — and if so, is it enough to point you in the direction of a custom embedded display?

For example, could a liquid spill disable the display’s controls in the middle of a safety-critical medical treatment?&nbsp;
Could pre-installed software interfere with the operation of essential performance?&nbsp;
What’s the impact of operating system (OS) updates on commercial off-the-shelf tablets?&nbsp;
Will the inclusion of a commercial device — like an iPad — prevent compliance with mandatory safety standards such as IEC 60601-1 for medical devices?
If your risk analysis process determines that an off-the-shelf phone or tablet does not introduce significant safety risk, then it can be evaluated against the remaining considerations below.

INLINE 03 Custom V Shelf BLOG template NEW 06

<h2>2: What’s Your Development Budget and Timeline?</h2>
Development budget and timelines are always a constraint — particularly for startups and lower revenue applications.&nbsp;
Prototype user interfaces can be more rapidly developed on an off-the-shelf tablet using industry-standard communication protocols like Bluetooth,&nbsp;because the hardware design is complete and better software tools for quick deployment exist.

For an embedded display, the mechanical design of the bezel and glass can be substantial, especially if the goal is to provide a similar look and feel to high-end consumer electronics such as the iPhone.&nbsp;
A custom embedded display will also introduce an electronic hardware development cycle which may be accelerated by leveraging proven designs.
By contrast, design verification cycles may be shorter for a custom display.&nbsp;
Software of unknown provenance (SOUP) and hardware/software combinations are reduced, resulting in fewer validation test cases required.

INLINE 05 Custom V Shelf BLOG template NEW 07

<h2>3: What Type of User Experience Are You Going For?</h2>
In addition to development considerations, embedded displays and off-the-shelf tablets have particular advantages and disadvantages when it comes to interaction design and user experience.&nbsp;
Off-the-shelf tablets have built-in operating systems that allow designers to use existing, familiar interaction design patterns.
For example, if the tablet you choose uses an Android operating system, designers can then make use of existing interaction patterns and UI components as a way to create interfaces.&nbsp;
While this may speed up the development process and provide users with an interface that is similar to their personal tablet, the perception of your product and the user experience it offers may leave something to be desired.

If your product requires a bespoke experience — like a combination of physical and digital buttons–an embedded display might make more sense and integrate more seamlessly with the physical design of your device.&nbsp;
This option would also be more appropriate if your users need a more distinct interface to perform tasks.&nbsp;
Embedded displays allow designers to “start from scratch” when designing digital experiences.
There are usually no pre-existing templates or styles from which to base your designs.&nbsp;
This means that designers can create interfaces that are more particular and tailored to your product.&nbsp;
This tailored approach leads to a more integrated experience with unique interactions that may instill more confidence in your users.

INLINE 07 Custom V Shelf BLOG template NEW 08

<h2>4: What’s Your Plan for Lifecycle Management?</h2>
The ongoing cost of supporting your device after its launch is another important consideration.&nbsp;
While an off-the-shelf tablet may provide quicker prototype development, it can also incur ongoing support efforts with supply chain management and software development.

Commercially available tablets are typically produced in very high volumes (millions per year) for durations of three years or less.&nbsp;
This could create supply management issues if your device is intended to be on the market for five years or longer, as is often the case for medical devices.&nbsp;
On the software side, a custom app running on off-the-shelf tablets may need regular modifications and testing to keep up with automatic OS updates and phone obsolescence.
With a custom embedded display, arrangements can be made with display manufacturers to ensure continued production of the same model over the product’s lifetime.&nbsp;
The embedded software OS can also be more carefully controlled, requiring less frequent updates after initial validation is completed.

INLINE 09 Custom V Shelf BLOG template NEW 09

<h2>5: Have You Calculated and Compared Your Cost of Goods?</h2>
Considering desired features and anticipated sales volume, either display solution could provide the lower manufacturing Cost of Goods (COGs).
 For example, a tablet may be inexpensive in low volume (&lt;100 pieces) and provide built-in features like Wi-fi and Bluetooth communication.&nbsp;
However, as production volumes increase, the cost of custom displays may fall rapidly and will not include unnecessary add-ons such as casework, battery, camera, etc. that are included in an off-the-shelf device.

If the customer is expected to provide their own tablet or phone to control the device, then the cost of goods should always be lower.
 Consider that this approach may introduce performance reliability issues if the hardware is not closely constrained (see what happened to Apple <a href="https://www.wired.com/2016/09/ios-10-bricks-iphones/">when they released ioS 10 and it bricked some iPhones</a>) which will drive up design validation and lifecycle support costs.
<h2>Digital-Physical Product Case Studies</h2>
At Delvep, we’ve designed devices that reflect all of the available options.
To read how we and our clients applied the above considerations during product development, check out these case studies:

HEADER helmetfit 01

<h3>HelmetFit’s Football Inflation System</h3>
This award-winning digital-physical product makes use of the user’s smartphone. It’s a football helmet inflation system with two components — an electric pump held in one hand (a mobile device clips into it) and an app — that communicate via Bluetooth.&nbsp;
The project team of industrial designers and mechanical engineers explored several initial configuration options before narrowing concepts to one that leverages the user’s phone. It was determined that connecting to a phone – as opposed to integrating an LED display into the pump – has many advantages. <a href="https://www.delve.com/work/helmetfit-football-helmet-inflation-system">Read more.</a>

1bruvelo hero

<h3>Bruvelo’s App Connected Coffeemaker</h3>
Bruvelo is a connected coffeemaker with a custom embedded display.&nbsp;
The project team’s electrical engineers researched and sourced the best operating system and embedded graphics library from a minimal cost platform, and integrated the hardware and software to match the UI and the client’s cost and performance requirements.&nbsp;
An embedded capacitive touchscreen allows flexibility to choose recipes or adjust parameters, but the primary interactions are kept relevant, contextual, and simple. <a href="https://www.delve.com/work/bruvelo-app-connected-coffeemaker">Read more.</a>

NEW20160701 analogic photo2

<h3>BK Ultrasound’s Sonic Window</h3>
This award-winning portable ultrasound device with a custom embedded display was new and unfamiliar for busy healthcare providers.&nbsp;
To make sure it would fit seamlessly into their routine, Delve conducted three rounds of user research. The project team used the results of this user research to generate early concepts for combined interaction and industrial design.&nbsp;
The result is a device whose user experience was described by one reporter as “a remote control crossed with an iPod.” <a href="https://www.delve.com/work/bk-ultrasound-sonic-window">Read more.</a>

HERO trice new

<h3>Trice Medical’s mi-eye Diagnostic Device</h3>
This medical device whose is the only fully integrated and disposable solution for the diagnosis of joint injuries. It combines a camera, a light source, and access needle in a single-use device.&nbsp;
Its initial custom display was switched out for an 0ff-the-shelf modified Surface tablet to cut manufacturing costs, open up software options for improved UI and expand the device’s capabilities. <a href="https://www.delve.com/work/trice-medical-mi-eye">Read more.</a>
As a final note, remember that if you’re deciding between touchscreen displays, be sure to carefully consider product risk, development budget and timeline, user experience, lifecycle management, and cost of goods sold before making your selection. And contact us if you need help weighing your options — we’re happy to assist as you make the best choice for your product!
Learn about&nbsp;our specialized knowledge about <a href="https://www.delve.com/services/iot-product-design">IoT Product Design</a>.

HEADR NEW offshelfcustom 01

Learn about the 5 important factors to consider when deciding between an off-the-shelf or custom embedded display for your digital interface.

Digital

Home

Insights

Off-the-Shelf or Custom Embedded Display for Your Digital-Physical Product?

Breadcrumbs

A full-service product design and strategic innovation consultancy.

Delve

Learn about the 5 important factors to consider when deciding between an off-the-shelf or custom embedded display for your digital interface.

description

generator

kSwNn6qD4B-4HloWnWMUBWQNpBx2_mPi3nMqgsh6ato

google-site-verification

factors, consider, deciding, off-the-shelf, custom, embedded, display, important, digital, learn, interface

keywords

https://cms.delve.com/assets/images/_1200x630_crop_center-center_82_none/HEADR_NEW_offshelfcustom-01.png?mtime=1657131088

https://linkedin.com/company/delvedesign/

Off-the-Shelf or Custom Embedded Display for Your Digital-Physical…

https://www.delve.com/insights/off-the-shelf-or-custom-embedded-display-for-your-digital-physical-product

referrer

robots

twitter:card

twitter:creator

twitter:description

https://cms.delve.com/assets/images/_800x418_crop_center-center_82_none/HEADR_NEW_offshelfcustom-01.png?mtime=1657131088

twitter:image

twitter:image:alt

twitter:image:height

twitter:image:width

twitter:site

twitter:title

{"title":{"title":"Off-the-Shelf or Custom Embedded Display for Your… | Delve"}}

Think Digital

Privacy Policy

FCOI Policy

Services

Industries

Our Work

What We Do

About Us

Our People

Work at Delve

Newsroom

Who We Are

Boston

Madison

Philadelphia

San Francisco

Our Studios

Contact Us

Contact

Read informative articles from Delve's team of experts. Discover innovative strategies and insights about product design, engineering, and development.

Delve Insights: Product Innovation & Development Blog

latest, unlock, here's, potential, experts, thinking

https://cms.delve.com/assets/images/_1200x630_crop_center-center_82_none/Delve_titlecard.png?mtime=1654035558

https://cms.delve.com/assets/images/_800x418_crop_center-center_82_none/Delve_titlecard.png?mtime=1654035558

Off-the-Shelf or Custom Embedded Display for Your Digital-Physical Product?

Off-the-Shelf or Custom Embedded Display for Your Digital-Physical Product?

Related Insights